Ludic Unreliability and Deceptive Game Design
Drawing from narratology and design studies, this article makes use of the notions of the ‘implied designer’ and ‘ludic unreliability’ to understand deceptive game design as a specific subset of transgressive game design. More specifically, in this text we present deceptive game design as the deliberate attempt to misguide players’ inferences about the designers’ intentions. Furthermore, we argue that deceptive design should not merely be taken as a set of design choices aimed at misleading players in their efforts to understand the game, but also as decisions devised to give rise to experiential and emotional effects that are in the interest of players. Finally, we propose to introduce a distinction between two varieties of deceptive design approaches based on whether they operate in an overt or a covert fashion in relation to player experience. Our analysis casts light on expressive possibilities that are not customarily part of the dominant paradigm of user-centered design, and can inform game designers in their pursuit of wider and more nuanced creative aspirations.
Big Breakfast Collective (2019). Waldo.io [Windows]. Digital game developed by Big Breakfast Collective, available online at: https://big-breakfast-collective.itch.io/waldoio, retrieved on March the 6th, 2021.
Chiku (2007). Syobon Action [Windows]. Digital game developed by Chiku, available online at: retrieved on August the 4th, 2021.
Fox, T. (2015). Undertale [Windows]. Digital game developed by Fox, T. and published by Fox, T.
FromSoftware (2011). Dark Souls [PlayStation 3]. Digital Game directed by Miyazaki, H., and published by Namco Bandai Games.
FromSoftware (2019). Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice [PlayStation 4]. Digital Game directed by Miyazaki, H., and published by Activision.
Gualeni, S. (2013). NECESSARY EVIL [Windows]. Digital Game developed with Dino Dini, Jimena Sánchez Sarquiz, Marcello Gómez Maureira, and Allister Brimble, available at online at https://evil.gua-le-ni.com, retrieved on August the 4th, 2021.
Kojima, I. (2001). Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty [PlayStation 2]. Digital Game Developed by Konami and Published by Konami.
Ninja Theory (2017). Hellblade: Senua’s Sacrifice [PlayStation 4]. Digital game directed by Antoniades, T. and published by Ninja Theory.
Nintendo EAD (1985). Super Mario Bros. [Famicom]. Digital game directed by Miyamoto, S. and developed by Nintendo EAD.
Nintendo EAD (1986). The Legend of Zelda [Famicom]. Digital game directed by Miyamoto, S. and Tezuka, T., and developed by Nintendo EAD.
Nintendo EAD (1987). The Legend of Zelda [NES]. Digital game directed by Miyamoto, S. and Tezuka, T., and developed by Nintendo EAD.
O’Reilly, M. (2007). I Wanna be the Guy: The Movie: The Game [Windows]. Digital game developed by O’Reilly, M.
Oshiba, H. (2016). Trap Adventure 2 [iOS]. Digital game developed by Oshiba, H.
The Fullbright Company (2013). Gone Home [Windows]. Digital game directed by Gaynor, S. and developed by The Fullbright Company.
Ubisoft Montreal (2014). Assassin’s Creed Unity [PlayStation 4]. Digital game directed by Amancio, A. and Albinet, M., and published by Ubisoft.
Budd, M. (2003). The Acquaintance Principle. British Journal of Aesthetics, 43(4), 386–392. https://doi.org/10.1093/bjaesthetics/43.4.386
Bogost, I. (2011). How to do things with videogames. Minneapolis, MI: University of Minnesota Press.
Bogost, I. (2016). Play anything: The pleasure of limits, the uses of boredom, and the secret of games. New York, NY: Basic Books.
Bonello Rutter Giappone, K. (2017). “Laughing otherwise: comic-critical approaches in alternative comedy”. Journal for Cultural Research, 21 (4), 394-413.
Currie, G. (1990). The Nature of Fiction. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.
Crilly, N., Good, D., Matravers, D., & Clarkson, P. J. (2008). “Design as Communication: Exploring the Validity and Utility of Relating Intention to Interpretation”. Design Studies 29.5, 425-457.
Flanagan, M. (2009). Critical play: Radical game design. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
Ford, D. (2018). “Speedrunning: Transgressive Play in Digital Space”. Proceedings of the 2018 DiGRA International Conference, July 25-28, Turin, Italy.
Gualeni, S. (2016). “Self-reflexive Videogames: Observations and Corollaries on Virtual Worlds as Philosophical Artifacts”. G|A|M|E – The Italian Journal of Game Studies, 5 (1).
Gualeni, S. (2019). “On the de-familiarizing and re-ontologizing effects of glitches and glitch-alikes”. Proceedings of the 2019 DiGRA international conference, Kyoto (Japan), August 6-10, 2019.
Gualeni, S.; Fassone, R.; Linderoth, J. (2019). “How to Reference a Digital Game”. Proceedings of the 2019 DiGRA international Conference, Kyoto (Japan), August 6-10, 2019.
Kafai, Y. B., Fields, D. A., & Giang, M. T. (2009). “Transgressive Gender Play: Profiles and Portraits of Girl Players in a Tween Virtual World”. Proceedings of the 2009 DiGRA International Conference, September 1-4, 2009, London, UK.
Kazmierczak, E. T. (2003). “Design as Meaning Making: From Making Things to the Design of Thinking”. Design Issues, 19 (2), 45-59.
Keighley, G. (2012) . “The Final Hours of Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty”. Available online at: https://www.gamespot.com/articles/the-final-hours-of-metal-gear-solid-2-sons-of-liberty/1100-6376810, retrieved on March the 6th, 2021.
Jenks, C. (2003). Transgression. London, UK: Routledge.
Jørgensen, K. & Karlsen, F. (eds.) (2019). Transgression in Games and Play. Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
Linderoth, J. (2012). “Why gamers don’t learn more: An ecological approach to games as learning environments”. Journal of Gaming & Virtual Worlds, 4 (1), 45-62.
Nguyen, C. T. (2020). Games: agency as art. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.
Paterson, E., Simpson-Williams, T., & Cordner, W. (2019). Once Upon a Pixel: Storytelling and Worldbuilding in Video Games. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
Pötzsch, H. (2019). “Forms and Practices of Transgressivity in Videogames: Aesthetics, Play, and Politics”. In Transgression in Games and Play, Jørgensen, K. & Karlsen, F. (eds.). Cambridge, MA: The MIT Press.
Purslow, M. (2017). “Hellblade’s permadeath bluff is “not as simple as people think””. Web article available online at: https://www.pcgamesn.com/hellblade-senuas-sacrifice/hellblade-permadeath-fake, retrieved on March the 6th, 2021.
Rapp, B. (2007). “Self-Reflexivity in Computer Games: Analyses of Selected Examples”. Self-Reference in the Media, 253-265.
Sageng, J. R. (2015). “Agential Properties in Computer Games”. In Philosophy of Emerging Media: Understanding, Appreciation, Application, Floyd, K. and Katz, J. E. (eds.). Oxford (UK): Oxford University Press.
Schmid, W. (2009). “Implied author.” In Handbook of Narratology, Hühn, P., Pier, J., Schmid, W., Schönert, J. (eds.). Berlin (Germany): De Gruyter, 161-173.
Tanenbaum, J. (2013). “How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Gamer: Reframing Subversive Play in Story-Based Games”. Proceedings of the 2013 DiGRA International Conference, August 26-29, Atlanta, Georgia, USA.
Traverso, M. (2019). “It’s ok to lie about your game”. Blogpost available at: https://big-breakfast-collective.itch.io/waldoio/devlog/94465/its-ok-to-lie-about-your-game, retrieved on March the 6th, 2021.Van de Mosselaer, N. & Gualeni, S. (2020). “The Implied Designer and the Experience of Gameworlds”. Proceedings of the 2020 DiGRA international Conference, Tampere (Finland), June 2-6, 2020.
Waszkiewicz, A. (2020). “‘Together They Are Twofold’: Player-Avatar Relationship Beyond the Fourth Wall”. Journal of Games Criticism, 4 (1).
Wilson, D., & Sicart, M. (2010). “Now it's personal: on abusive game design”. Proceedings of the 2010 FDG International Conference in Monterrey, California, USA.
Youngblood, J. (2017). “‘I Wouldn’t Even Know the Real Me Myself’: Queering Failure in Metal Gear Solid 2”. In Shaw, A. & Ruberg B. (eds.). 2017. Queer Game Studies. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.
Zagal, J. P., Björk, S., & Lewis, C. (2013). “Dark patterns in the design of games”. Proceedings of the 2013 FDG International Conference, May 14-17, Chania, Crete, Greece.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright in their articles and grant the Journal of the Philosophy of Games (JPG) right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under the following licence: Creative Commons Licence : CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. The licence allows others to share the work for non-commercial purposes with an acknowledgement of the work’s authorship and initial publication in this journal, but does not allow others to create derivative works based on the work without the author’s permission.
- Authors are allowed to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal’s published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), provided that such distribution includes an acknowledgement of the article’s initial publication in JPG.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access). Authors who distribute their work after its acceptance by JPG but prior to its publication agree to indicate on the manuscript that it will be published in JPG. Authors agree that they will not publish their work in any other journals, anthologies, or monographs before the date on which their work is published by JPG.
- Authors grant JPG a royalty-free, non-exclusive, perpetual, worldwide license to create derivative works based on their articles and to publish their articles or any part of their articles in compilations and anthologies.
In special cases, it may be possible for the author to negotiate an open licence other than the CC BY-NC-ND.